3 Superbowl rings > none h:

 

I doubt it

 

QFT

Besides, Manning and the Colts will choke in the playoffs as they always do.

 

QFT

 

so that means Cederic Wilson > Randy Moss because Wilson has a superbowl ring? ummm no
Manning > Brady any day of the week.

 

Brady still has a better record when they face off head to head, so thats why Brady is better, not to mention he can win the big games. when I say big games, I mean playoff games. Manning always chokes. until he can make it to the superbowl, Brady will be better. Brady lost his best recievers this year and look what he's done this season. Manning has had Harrison, and Wayne for years. thus Brady is betterh:

 

since it's a team sport you can't blame manning alone for losing. I think brady is one of the better qbs in the game right now but manning is the best.

manning
Year G Cmp Att Pct Yds Yds/Att TD Int 1st Sck Rtg
2006 8 183 281 65.1 2291 8.2 17 3 125 10 106

brady
Year G Cmp Att Pct Yds Yds/Att TD Int 1st Sck Rtg
2006 8 155 267 58.1 1799 6.7 14 8 98 12 83.5

which would you rather have?

 

Brady got plain unlucky...2 tipped INT's, right?

 

in a playoff game, I'll take Brady every time. Manning is a great QB, but he's kind of like Marino. He's king of the stats, but can't win the big game. Brady is more like Montana, he just wins.
I love watching the two face off, its one of the best matchups in football. I'd love to see Manning and Brady both inducted to the hall of fame some day in the same class, it would just be so fitting.