in a playoff game, I'll take Brady every time. Manning is a great QB, but he's kind of like Marino. He's king of the stats, but can't win the big game. Brady is more like Montana, he just wins.
I love watching the two face off, its one of the best matchups in football. I'd love to see Manning and Brady both inducted to the hall of fame some day in the same class, it would just be so fitting.