Hmm...Wouldnt 215/40/17 be more consistant with your rolling diameter, considering if you have a 5g.

Tires i would put my money on:

Bridestone S03 (ultimate wet and excellent Dry)
BFGoodrich KD (ultimate Dry)
Falken Azenis (cant be beat for the value)
Toyo Proxes and Michilen Pilot Sport(expensive) are very good too.

All things considered, i would go with the s-03