So my ex calls me
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 216
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by CiviChik97
i dont mean to burst your bubble here, but that's illegal. you have to tell her before you start recording that she's being recorded.
.
.
.
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 12,945
Likes: 0
From: York PA
Originally Posted by reno96teg
illegal? if he tries to use it against her, maybe. but to defend himself, i'm pretty sure it's legit. otherwise, all he needs is a tone that plays every few seconds (that indicates that the line is being recorded), and he's all set. :thumbup:
when the celica was messed up, the kid that did it was going to come talk to us all with his mom...Kevin was allowed to ask whatever he wanted. We were going to record him, without him knowing so he wouldnt be reluctant to say certain things, but we asked the Officer on the case and he said that we HAD to tell him that he was being recorded. I don't know if the law varies from state to state, but i know that's how it is in PA. It doesnt matter why you're recording them, they HAVE to know that it's being done.
and, wouldnt using it to defend himself, ultimately be using it against her? :thinking:
Registered User
Joined: Apr 2004
Posts: 216
Likes: 0
just a metaphor....like u trying to protect yourself from something and your action is ILLEGAL.
ex: u got a flu shot and your friends sue your butt off cuz they claim that you didn't tell them about it so they was 10 hours trying to give u a flu. u heard!!!
ex: u got a flu shot and your friends sue your butt off cuz they claim that you didn't tell them about it so they was 10 hours trying to give u a flu. u heard!!!
.
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 12,945
Likes: 0
From: York PA
Originally Posted by asianthug_ak47
just a metaphor....like u trying to protect yourself from something and your action is ILLEGAL.
ex: u got a flu shot and your friends sue your butt off cuz they claim that you didn't tell them about it so they was 10 hours trying to give u a flu. u heard!!!
ex: u got a flu shot and your friends sue your butt off cuz they claim that you didn't tell them about it so they was 10 hours trying to give u a flu. u heard!!!
ok, i didnt make the law... and i dont think your metaphor is a good example. the flu shot??? c'mon.
Moderator
Joined: Dec 2000
Posts: 21,573
Likes: 0
Originally Posted by CiviChik97
and, wouldnt using it to defend himself, ultimately be using it against her? :thinking:
if you call me, tell me you're going to frame me for something, and then do it.. when i get accused of it, i think i can say, "listen to this recording, it wasn't me!"
but if you call me, tell me something compromising, i record it, and bring to someone and say, "listen to this! arrest her!" or whatever.. i think that's when it becomes inadmissible.
but then again, i'm no lawyer.
.
Joined: Sep 2002
Posts: 12,945
Likes: 0
From: York PA
Originally Posted by reno96teg
well, i think the difference is..
if you call me, tell me you're going to frame me for something, and then do it.. when i get accused of it, i think i can say, "listen to this recording, it wasn't me!"
but if you call me, tell me something compromising, i record it, and bring to someone and say, "listen to this! arrest her!" or whatever.. i think that's when it becomes inadmissible.
but then again, i'm no lawyer.
if you call me, tell me you're going to frame me for something, and then do it.. when i get accused of it, i think i can say, "listen to this recording, it wasn't me!"
but if you call me, tell me something compromising, i record it, and bring to someone and say, "listen to this! arrest her!" or whatever.. i think that's when it becomes inadmissible.
but then again, i'm no lawyer.
k, i see what you're getting at.
