Thanks for the condolences everyone. Here's the latest picture of the car (taken by WiLL) I have.

It kind of sucks but I haven't taken any real pictures of the whole car in a long time.

I actually just got the paperwork in the mail recently. When I spoke to the claims adjuster, she told me that it would help if I have my receipts for certain items. I don't know if they will somehow reimburse me for the items or if they will just plug "custom wheels" into the computer (like you do on KBB.com) for an estimate. If that's the case, it's not looking good.
Unfortunately, I'm kicking myself big time. In the beginning, I never intended to have this car be anything special (even when it was stolen, it didn't look like anything more than a lowered sedan with rims). That's why I called it Fodoho. But as time went by, I added a few things here and there and planned on getting an alarm. I had a Club but I didn't use it at the time. Let this be a warning to everyone. If you've got it, use it! Of course everyone says that any theif can get a car they want and this is very true. But if you can add that extra few seconds of annoyance (and make a thief look like a thief to people walking by), it's at least something.
Yeah, I know what you mean. I've had a previous car broken into in the past but I've never had a car stolen before. I always figured that they'd just rip parts off and break into it, and was in denial that they'd take the whole freakin' car.
Thanks dood.