Usually if the wheel is strong and light (and devoid of triple-plated chrome surfaces), chances are, everyone will like it. If the wheel matches the above conditions minus the "light" part, then everyone but the moderators will like it.

h:
My 17" Volks weigh 14 lbs, so I could care less when people gripe about the "performance loss" when going to a larger wheel. Larger wheels are a strictly appearance only mod. I just paid extra to get light wheels and thus happen to have the added benefit of not losing too much in terms of speed.
Shingo