nothing can touch my voot and secret of mana
other than that i find it hard to rank games against each other

FEAR has a great single player mode (i have not had the pleasure of gears of war. let me know when it is released for pc) and puts it at the top of its class in my book. but i prefer the multiplayer modes of quake and unreal to fear so i dont know how to judge those games against each other

shining force as a whole gets big praise from me but when i break it down it comes to individual attn to a wide variety of playable characters (leveling up) that is the appeal of the series

Mobile Suit Gundam Seed: Federation vs. Z.A.F.T. could take up the absence left by voot but as the game is not widely known, not US released, and people seem to still prefer 2D fighting to 3D fighting, i dont think i can get the potential out of this game

off the top of my head i think ff7 would rank higher than tp
ill have to think about more