Well, I decided to go out with Goo-Gone and a razor blade and give it another shot. I got all the shit off with only minor scratches and dings to the clear coat. It looks good from a distance but up close you can see the scratches. I'm not too worried though, I plan on taking it to Maaco anyways to get some dings removed, surface rust removed, and repainted later this summer. Thanks for the help guys.