OK so tie them both to a tree in a wooded area and start a new survivor series. I feel there is more to this story. To many questions and your girl obviously is hiding something if she doesnt what this guy to do time, or worse get his neck snapped. Probe her for details and then I would confront the guy and see what he says. Have her call him and listen in or somthing. I know she wont do that but its a thought.