Originally Posted by Consumer Reports
SEDAN Less than $20,000
Honda Civic
Redesigned for 2006, the new Civic ($17,000 to $20,000) has a roomy
interior, a comfortable ride, and good handling and fuel economy. Manual- and automatic-transmission versions get 31 and 28 mpg overall. The hybrid gets 37 mpg overall. Curtain air bags are standard and crash-test results are impressive.
SEDAN $20,000-$30,000
Honda Accord
The Accord provides an excellent balance of comfort, roominess, and handling. Each model provides good fuel economy for its class, with the four-cylinder and V6 models getting 23 and 24 mpg overall. The Hybrid delivers quicker acceleration and moderately better gas mileage of 25 mpg overall.
SEDAN $30,000-$40,000
Acura TL
The TL is among the highest-scoring sedans we’ve tested. It provides a near-ideal blend of comfort, convenience, and sportiness--all at a reasonable $33,700. It handles well and delivers a controlled, quiet ride. The interior has excellent fit and finish. The TL is quick, while still getting a commendable 23 mpg.
LUXURY SEDAN
Infiniti M35
The M35 provides an excellent balance of performance, comfort, and handling. Available in rear- or all-wheel drive, the V6-powered M35x (about $50,000) is as capable threading a twisty road as it is cruising on the highway. A $69,000 V8-powered M45 model is also available.
SUV Less than $30,000
Subaru Forester
The Forester is a good vehicle and a good value--about $23,000 for the 2.5X. This car-based, all-wheel-drive SUV handles nimbly and rides comfortably. The $24,000 Honda CR-V is a very good runner-up, with more room and standard electronic stability control (ESC).
SUV More than $30,000
Toyota Highlander Hybrid
The Highlander Hybrid ($35,000 to $40,000) is a well-rounded SUV with quick acceleration, a comfortable ride, and a third-row seat. Its 22 overall mpg is impressive for a midsized SUV. This hybrid and its near twin, the 23-mpg Lexus RX400h ($50,000), are the only SUVs to achieve an excellent overall score in our testing. Another excellent choice, with a better third-row seat, is the Honda Pilot ($29,000 to $35,000).
PICKUP TRUCK
Honda Ridgeline
The Honda Ridgeline ($28,000-$35,000) redefines the pickup, combining the comfortable ride and agile handling of a car-based chassis with a good payload capacity. The roomy cab features nice details and is easy to access. It even offers a weather-tight trunk in the bed. If you want a longer bed and more towing capacity, we suggest the Toyota Tundra.
MINIVAN
Honda Odyssey
The Honda Odyssey ($26,000 to $37,000) leads the minivan class with agility, refinement, and interior flexibility. ESC and curtain air bags are standard. The interior is well crafted and comfortable. The Toyota Sienna ($25,000 to $39,000), another high scorer, is quieter, rides more comfortably, and offers all-wheel drive, but is less agile.
GREEN CAR
Toyota Prius
For the third year, this $23,000 gasoline/electric hybrid is our pick, thanks to its excellent 44-mpg overall fuel economy. It is certified by the California Air Resources Board as a near-zero-emission vehicle. With a roomy interior, reasonable performance, and the versatility of a hatchback, the Prius is a good alternative to a midsized sedan.
FUN TO DRIVE
Subaru Impreza WRX / STi
The Impreza WRX and its high-performance STi variant ($25,000 and $33,000, respectively) prove that you don’t have to spend a lot of money or give up practicality to get a fun-to-drive sports car. They blend quick acceleration and very agile handling with the versatility of a four-door sedan or wagon (WRX only).