Hey, I wanted everyones opinion on, what would be the most reasonable path.

Some ass, 4x4 decided to drive over the front drivers side of my car, (its an ongoing war up here) 4x4 vs Sport Compact, any how, somone smashed my fender, and busted my corner light and headlight bracket, I got the corner and headlight bracket, and fixed them, but I wanted to know what the best path would be. Should I get 2 new fiberglass fenders, and do some bodywork to make them fit right, or should I get a fender from a yard? I am going to paint my car in the next 6 months, so color matching is not really a problem for now...