I would definitely lean towards the Integra. Same year and same mileage, the Integra will be more expensive. But if your goals are performance or looks, the Integra is the definite choice. First of all, the Integra is faster stock (and to get a Civic as fast an a stock Integra, especially a Civic DX or CX) would probably even out the price. On top of that, the Integra handles better stock, has a niecr interior (imo), better seats, and the exterior styling is nicer than a Civic (plus, there aren't as many Integra's as Civic's around, so its a little more unique). So in conclusion, Integra > Civic