Maybe its the whole idea of puting plastic over plastic to give the light a low profile look that people dont like. I dont really see any other option, but,to me these lids look the best to date compared to all the others. All the lids I've seen cover a good portion of the light making it a bit obvious that you are covering the light whereas these eyelids cover just a little bit.

Essentialy all eyelids are plastic cut and fitted for the specific year of the car. Just not painted from the factory. Some are made out of other material like carbon fiber.