You are lucky it was your front fenders, I was hit in a hit and run, and they hit my car from right behind the passenger side door all the way back to behind the wheel well on my 98 2 door GS. I ended up paying $1500 to get it clipped but it looks amazing and i am happy with the job. If I would have went through insurance my insurance would have went up about $500 so figured why not just pay to fix it myself.

As for the fenders, I would deffinetely just look through google as Kai said earlier because it seems as if most people that change their fenders just get the bmw z3 fenders, which in my opinion are just overdone and don't look to good on the car. If I were you I would look for the stock fenders and do a lip kit on your car because too many people have the rice look and don't seem to care about a clean looking car. I decided to just put TypeR sideskirts and a mugen lip on the car and am looking for a rear bumper lip because I hate being able to see my muffler in back.