IMO, Cheney won hands down. Edwards went off on too many tangents, evaded answering more questions and couldn't let things go. What I remember most was when the moderator posed the question of the Aids virus and what would be done *here* and not in china, africa, etc. Edwards went back to talking about taxes or something, then he decided to talk about giving more aid to africa and russia for Aids.

They both dodged some questions and responses, but I think Edwards really didn't come out on top of this one.