I've used www.partmartone.com and was very pleased, but their site is down...here's their ebay store: http://stores.ebay.com/PARTMARTONE. My front bumper I got from them fit great and was OEM quality. They'll even paint it for you and ship it that way.

I also found http://www.autotruckbumper.com/hon-civic-96.html
http://www.oembumpers.com/catalog/in...aa0fad3da48099 (might have to call)