I think your option number two is a better choice in my opinion, frankly I can't justify spending the money on a front that is so vulnerable and not having it be taken care of by insurance (I know some places insure aftermarket parts, I am just trying to make a point). Also I am somewhat biased because currently I am going for the USDM OEM "clean look" since the '98 GSR is already taken care of I have augmented the appearence by the full OEM Type R underbody kit and yellow highs, but I am also working towards the fogs. Just my 2 cents. Good luck with whatever you decide.