Originally Posted by MrFatbooty

Oddly enough, this dissection of the video is being done by a website that seeks to get rid of Donald Rumsfeld. They are claiming it's a "false flag" video made to get people angry at arabs again and want to support the Iraq war effort.

Even though I wouldn't mind seeing Rumsfeld gone myself, I can't ignore the fact that all this website has really done is point out flaws and then say, "because of all these flaws the video is faked." That's not a very strong way to make an argument. There is no deductive logic which moves from premises to conclusion, it's just throwing a bunch of stuff out there and saying, "see, we're right because of all this stuff."