both stick, but the maxima is auto? how does that work?
Anyway it would depend on the year of the Max, and the mods on both cars.
Say stock for stock the lude will own the auto max if its a Maxima older than 2k1. If both are stick then the Maxima will take it on a 1/4 mile run but the lude will pull on the Max on the highway if its a 90-99 Max.