"Depends on what you are shooting and your style really. I mean a clean shot is always the desired result in the end most times....but how do you account for the thousands of Holga users? The Holga is crap from the start but the amazing images it produces are unique to it."

Thats easy -- Holgas cost about 20 bucks and the next least expensive medium format body is... what... $150? =) A Holga is a great way to experiment with 120 without spending hundreds on a body and a lens.

Film versus digital is the same argument as PC versus Mac. It ought to not be about which tool is superior, but which is superior for the job you're trying to get done.