ipod all the way!! i got a free 15 gig iPod from work and i love it!! its so nice and sleek, takes up arounde 3700 songs. The touch screen is nice and it has a nice bright white light. Only thing is that the accessories are a bit expensive but thats not too bad all you'll need is a docking station and maybe some rca wires if you want to put in your car like i'm doing.