before/after pics would help...i just got rearended this summer too...and when i was asking around for quotes...my friend's dad's friend owns a body shop...and they do really good, reputable work, and they do all the work for a closeby Honda dealership...and he said that cars over 2 years old most of the time will get remanufactured body parts...and another guy i was talking with said that remanufactured doesn't really fit as well and the parts aren't perfectly OEM spec (in terms of dimensions, lil short here or there)...so that mite be what happened...but if u can show the guy pics of before/after and it really bugs u...u can prolly get a better job done