Damn Mandi....what the hell?
Well, you're better than that

Just tell her either come get it or it's going in the trash. No, she can't sue you for it. She left in it your possession at YOUR house. You never agreed to keep it safe for her and you made attempts at giving it back. In fact, you can sue her for storage fees....HAHAHAHAHA
Anyway, good luck with everything. Call me if you want to talk...you have my #