Originally posted by Eklypse39
it's a tough call ... but if all games were released on all systems, the Xbox does have superior graphics, sound, loading times, and on point controls. look at soul calibur II ... it really puts the GC and PS2 versions to shame.
if all games were exclusive and games would only appear on 1 system ... i'd go for the GC. there's nothing like those nintendo exclusive titles like Mario Sunshine, Metroid, and Zelda.
but ... i'd have to say PS2. they have the right blend of 3rd party and exclusive titles. (Madden, GTA, GT, Final Fantasy) they don't have the best controller (GC), but it's damn good enough (much better than the Xbox's). their graphics aren't as smooth as the Xbox, but it can definately hold it's own. the PS2 is just a really balanced machine.
great point.
If you do decide to go XBOX, make sure you get the "controller S"... its SOOOOO much better than the fatty, and pretty close to the competitor's